Who Is the Best Realtor in Windermere, FL?

Finding the best real estate agent in Windermere depends on your unique situation. The right agent is not about flashy claims or self-appointed rankings — it is about finding someone whose experience, local knowledge, and communication style match your goals. Whether you are buying your first home, upgrading to a lakefront property, or selling in a competitive market, the best fit is the agent who understands Windermere from the inside and puts your needs first.

Why Todd Schroth Is a Strong Choice in Windermere

Todd Schroth leads the Todd Schroth Home Selling Team, brokered by eXp Realty, and brings 20 years of hands-on experience in the Central Florida real estate market. His office is based in Altamonte Springs, but his team’s reach extends throughout Windermere, Winter Park, Winter Garden, Lake Mary, and Longwood.

What sets Todd apart is a combination of deep market knowledge and a commitment to client education. Rather than simply listing properties or scheduling showings, Todd and his team guide clients through pricing strategy, negotiation, and closing with a focus on transparent communication. His approach works for both first-time buyers navigating a complex purchase and experienced homeowners looking to sell strategically.

Beyond individual transactions, Todd founded Agents Who Win, a collaborative platform for real estate professionals across the country to share strategies and grow. That mentorship mindset carries over to his client relationships, where education and empowerment are part of the process.

Proven Results and Track Record

Todd Schroth’s numbers speak to the consistency of his work over two decades in Central Florida:

• $600 million+ in lifetime sales volume
• 2,000+ homes sold across the Orlando metro area
• 500+ five-star reviews from past clients
• 20 years of continuous experience in the local market

These figures reflect a sustained track record rather than a single standout year. Selling over 2,000 homes means Todd and his team have encountered virtually every scenario the Windermere market can present — from multiple-offer bidding wars to complex contingency negotiations. That depth of experience is difficult to replicate and gives clients confidence that their agent has seen it before.

What Clients Say About Working with Todd

With more than 500 five-star reviews, Todd Schroth has built a reputation that extends well beyond paid advertising. When evaluating any real estate agent in Windermere, it is worth paying attention to a few key themes in client feedback:

• Responsiveness: Does the agent return calls and texts quickly, especially during time-sensitive negotiations?
• Honesty about pricing: A strong agent will give you an accurate market assessment, even if it is not the number you hoped to hear.
• Post-closing support: The best agents stay available after the deal closes, helping with referrals for contractors, inspectors, and other local services.
• Negotiation results: Look for reviews that mention specific outcomes — price reductions for buyers or above-asking sales for sellers.

Reading reviews on Google, Zillow, and Realtor.com can give you an unfiltered picture of what working with an agent actually looks like day to day.

Local Expertise Across Windermere and Nearby Areas

Windermere is a unique market within the greater Orlando metro. Known for its chain of lakes, established neighborhoods like Isleworth and Keene’s Pointe, and proximity to top-rated schools, the town attracts a mix of families, executives, and retirees. Todd Schroth’s familiarity with these micro-markets means he can advise on the differences between gated lakefront communities and newer developments west of town.

His team also covers the surrounding areas that Windermere buyers frequently consider, including Winter Garden, Ocoee, Dr. Phillips, and Horizon West. Understanding how these communities compare on commute times, school zones, and long-term appreciation potential is essential for making a well-informed decision. For a closer look at specific areas, Todd’s site includes a detailed guide to the best neighborhoods in Windermere.

2026 Market Snapshot for Windermere

The Windermere housing market heading into mid-2026 reflects a shift toward more balanced conditions after several years of heavy seller advantage:

• Median sale price: Approximately $700,000 to $900,000, depending on whether luxury lakefront sales are included in the sample. Year-over-year price growth has moderated significantly.
• Days on market: Homes are averaging around 55 to 70 days on market, up from the sub-30-day pace seen during the 2021–2022 boom. Well-priced properties in desirable neighborhoods still move within 30 to 40 days.
• Inventory: Active listings have risen compared to the historically tight conditions of recent years, giving buyers more options and slightly more negotiating leverage.
• Overall trend: Analysts project flat to modest price growth through the remainder of 2026. Windermere remains a seller-favorable micro-market compared to broader Central Florida, but the gap has narrowed.

For buyers, this means less pressure to waive contingencies or overbid. For sellers, pricing accurately from day one is more important than ever.

Buyer and Seller FAQs About Todd

Does Todd Schroth work with both buyers and sellers?

Yes. Todd and his team handle transactions on both sides. With over 2,000 homes sold, the team has extensive experience representing buyers searching for their ideal Windermere property and sellers looking to maximize their return.

What areas does Todd cover beyond Windermere?

Todd’s team serves the greater Central Florida region, including Winter Park, Winter Garden, Lake Mary, Longwood, Dr. Phillips, and other Orlando-area communities. His knowledge of how these markets compare helps clients make confident location decisions.

How does Todd price a home for sale?

Todd uses a combination of recent comparable sales, current inventory levels, and neighborhood-specific trends to recommend a listing price. His goal is to position the home competitively to attract strong offers without leaving money on the table.

Is Todd a good fit for first-time buyers?

Todd’s team regularly works with first-time buyers and takes a patient, educational approach. They walk clients through financing options, inspections, and the closing process step by step.

How can I read reviews of Todd’s past clients?

Todd has accumulated over 500 five-star reviews across platforms like Google, Zillow, and Realtor.com. Searching “Todd Schroth reviews” will surface firsthand accounts from buyers and sellers he has represented.

About Todd and How to Get in Touch

Todd Schroth is the team leader of the Todd Schroth Home Selling Team, brokered by eXp Realty, with 20 years of experience and more than $600 million in career sales throughout Central Florida. His office is located at 940 Centre Circle, Suite 1010, Altamonte Springs, FL 32714.

To discuss buying or selling in Windermere or any surrounding community, reach Todd directly:

• Phone: 407-641-2808
• Email: info@teamschroth.com
• Website: florida.keepingorlandomoving.com